How to File a Background Check Dispute — Your Rights under the FCRA
Errors in background checks often occur when data gets mis-matched, someone else’s record appears under your name, or outdated/incorrect information is used. Even minor mistakes can cause job offers or housing applications to be rejected unfairly.
The FCRA gives you important protections: you’re entitled to access your report, dispute inaccurate information, and receive notice if an adverse decision is made based on that report. Knowing your rights helps you act quickly and hold screening companies accountable.
Common Errors That Lead to a Background Check Dispute
Background checks mistakes are more frequent than many realize — and they can derail job offers, rental applications, or other opportunities. Understanding the main types of mistakes helps you spot an issue early and act before the damage grows.
Mixed or mismatched identities is one of the most serious errors is when your details get mixed with someone else’s record — often someone with a similar name or Social Security number. The result: you wind up appearing with someone else’s criminal history, eviction record, or debt.
Outdated, sealed, or expunged records still appearing. Records that should no longer be visible — such as convictions that were sealed or dismissed — may still show up in a background check. Even though you believe your record is cleared, screening reports may continue to list active negative items.
Incorrect or incomplete criminal record listingsSometimes the wrong offense is listed, key details are missing, or the status of a charge (e.g., “no charges filed”) isn’t shown. These kinds of mistakes misrepresent your history and unfairly increase the risk perception from employers or landlords.
What to look out for
Verify that your name, date of birth, and Social Security number are spelled and typed correctly.
Look for criminal or eviction records listed under your file — check if they match your history.
Check if records are labeled “sealed,” “expunged,” or “dismissed” when they should be.
Watch for someone else’s record under your name — especially if you have a common name or shared identifiers.
Identify repeated entries of the same event (which can exaggerate the impact).
Recognizing these common error types helps you act quickly when something looks off in your background check report. Early identification increases your chances of correcting issues before they impact your opportunities.
Consumer FCRA Rights During the Background Check Process
Right to disclosure and consent. Before a background check firm or employer obtains your consumer report, you must be clearly informed in writing that a report will be obtained, and you must give your written authorization. In employment settings, this disclosure must be a stand-alone document, separate from your job application, and must make clear that your background report will be used. Without your explicit consent and this disclosure, the report may be in violation of FCRA rules.
Right to know what’s in the report. If a screening company produces a consumer report about you, you have the right to request a copy of that report and to know the sources and identifiers used. You also have the right to obtain a free copy of your report if an adverse action (such as a job denial or rental rejection) is taken because of the report. This ensures you can examine exactly what information was used against you.
Right to dispute inaccuracies. One of the most powerful protections under the FCRA is your right to dispute any inaccurate, incomplete, or unverifiable information found in a consumer report. When you submit a dispute to the CRA or screening agency, pointing out errors such as wrong names, mixed records, sealed or expunged charges still appearing, the agency must conduct a “reasonable investigation” within approximately 30 days and correct or delete the information if the dispute is verified.
Pre-adverse action and adverse-action notices. If a user (employer or landlord) plans to take negative action against you based on a consumer report, you must be given a “pre-adverse action” notice. This notice should include a copy of the report, a statement of your rights under the FCRA, and the contact details for the CRA that issued the report. After the final decision is made, you must receive an “adverse action” notice that informs you the decision is based on the report, provides the CRA’s name and contact information, and reiterates that you have the right to dispute the report.
Right to accuracy and privacy. The FCRA obligates CRAs to maintain “reasonable procedures to assure maximum possible accuracy” of the information in your file. This means data cannot be unreasonably outdated, misidentified, or left unchanged when you’ve successfully disputed it. Also, when public record information (like criminal records) is used.
Right to legal recourse. If your rights under the FCRA are violated, for example, if you were denied a job based on a flawed report, or the screening agency failed to investigate your dispute you may be able to sue for damages. The law allows for statutory damages (even if you can’t prove quantifiable loss), actual damages (lost wages or job opportunities), and attorney’s fees if you win. This puts leverage in your hands: you’re not just powerless — the law gives you a means to hold agencies accountable for failures.
Need to dispute an error on your background report?
Step-by-Step Guide: How to File a Background Check Dispute
The first step is to request your screening or consumer report. If you’ve been subjected to a background check (for employment, housing, licensing), ask for a copy of the report and identify which consumer-reporting agency or screening vendor produced it.
Next, identify and document the errors in the report. Look for incorrect personal information (name, birthdate, SSN), records that don’t belong to you, sealed or dismissed items still present, or mixed-file issues where someone else’s record is linked to your identity. Take screenshots, copy relevant entries, collect court documents, dismissal letters — any proof showing the record is wrong or outdated.
Then, send a formal dispute to the agency and/or vendor listed in the report. Your dispute should clearly list each item you believe is inaccurate, explain why it’s wrong, and attach supporting documentation. The reporting agency must conduct a reasonable investigation, typically within 30 days, and correct or delete any verified inaccuracies.
After filing the dispute, follow up and track the investigation. Note the date you submitted the dispute, keep copies of all correspondence, and check back with the agency. Once the investigation concludes, review the findings to ensure the incorrect items were removed or corrected.
Finally, monitor what happens after the investigation. Even if corrections are made, ensure downstream users (employers, landlords) were informed if the inaccurate report was used against you. Continue to monitor your file periodically to catch any reinserted or duplicate errors. Maintaining oversight helps protect against repeated misuse of inaccurate data.
What to Do If the Dispute Doesn’t Solve the Issue
If your dispute does not result in a correction, the next step is knowing when to escalate. If the agency or screening company fails to conduct a proper investigation, ignores your evidence, or continues reporting information you proved to be inaccurate, you may need legal help.
Consulting an attorney experienced in background checks and consumer rights issues is advisable when damage has occurred, such as lost job offers, housing denials, or reputational harm.
You should also understand the potential remedies available under consumer-reporting laws. If you’ve suffered because a background-check vendor or employer violated your rights, you may be entitled to statutory damages (even without showing quantifiable loss), actual damages (lost wages, extra fees, or denied opportunities), and recovery of attorney’s fees and costs.
Additionally, protecting yourself for future background checks is key. Make it a habit to request copies of reports used against you, maintain accurate records of your identifiers, and proactively dispute errors before they're used against you. If you applied for a job or rental and gave consent for a report, keep a copy of the pre-adverse or adverse action notice you receive, and stay alert for incorrect items creeping back in.
If the initial process fails, acting promptly — with documentation, legal oversight, and ongoing monitoring — gives you the best chance to neutralize ongoing harm and restore your reputation.
Contact Us
Have you been a victim of an inaccurate background check, or have other questions? Contact us!
